Savory sandwiches at Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley feature meat, cheese, and vegetable fillings, with pickup available for your meal.
Order onlineMorning Bliss
$13.75
A French toast sandwich with eggs, bacon, melted cheese, and syrup.
“Honestly some reviews are harsh on here but i can honestly say that the food was great. Very cute ambiance and staff was nice. My friend and me had the avocado toast along with the french toast. Both meals were really good! Will be coming back!”
Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese
$7.50
Taylor ham, egg, and melted cheese fill a warm breakfast roll.
“Had the Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich and a cappuccino recently. Great meal, great coffee and I loved the presentation. With the beautiful atmosphere and welcoming staff I received makes this a top place to visit. 10/10 will highly recommend to my colleagues in the area.”
Nutley Chicken Sandwich
$15.50
A chicken sandwich, with its specific bread and toppings not listed.
“Came here with 3 friends and wow… the food was delishhh. The service was exceptional from start to finish, which made the whole experience even better. We basically turned brunch into a tasting, and yes I tried all of my friends dishes lol, from the chicken sandwich, chicken & waffles, mac and cheese, and the Notorious B.L.T… and honestly, every single dish hit. Highly recommend this spot for brunch. You really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu !”
Chicken Club
$15.00
Grilled chicken club with avocado, bacon, tomato, and smoked cheese.
Illmatic Prosciutto Press
$16.50
Toasted ciabatta with prosciutto, mozzarella, peppers and arugula.
“Enjoyed a great stash green jasmine tea and a breakfast sandwich. The barista was so sweet and totally amazing!”
Passaic Ave Turkey Pesto Press
$16.00
Toasted ciabatta layers turkey, pesto aioli, peppers, arugula, and provolone.
“The milkshake was amazing + pesto turkey press is very tasty. Fresh salad. Awesome aesthetics.”
Sugar Tree Cafe sandwiches pair roasted turkey with pesto aioli on toasted ciabatta, while crushed chickpeas meet celery, dill, onion, parsley, lettuce, and tomato on toasted multigrain bread.
Chicken Club layers grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, tomato, and smoked cheese. Hummus Sandwich has spinach and feta. Morning Bliss stacks French toast with scrambled eggs, bacon, cheese, and syrup.
Order in Nutley for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. The Sugar Tree Benny Croissant fills a golden, flaky croissant with avocado and two soft-poached eggs, finished with rich hollandaise-style sauce.
