Lunch in Nutley

Savory toast and ciabatta presses make lunch at Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley a mix of chicken, turkey, and prosciutto for pickup.

Order online

Lunch to Try

Passaic Ave Turkey Pesto Press

$16.00

Toasted ciabatta layers turkey, pesto aioli, peppers, arugula, and provolone.

“The milkshake was amazing + pesto turkey press is very tasty. Fresh salad. Awesome aesthetics.”

The Hamptons Chicken Salad Toast

$15.75

Sourdough toast with chicken, celery, vegan mayo, guacamole, and a pickle.

“I’ve been to Sugar Tree a number of times and I’ve never left disappointed! The food is consistently delicious — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Whether you're stopping in for brunch, lunch, or a sweet treat, everything on the menu is a hit. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the staff are always friendly and attentive, especially Stella who went above and beyond. It’s such a fun spot to relax, catch up on work, socialize with friends, or just treat yourself. Highly recommend!”

Illmatic Prosciutto Press

$16.50

Toasted ciabatta with prosciutto, mozzarella, peppers and arugula.

Find Something Special at Sugar Tree Cafe

Sugar Tree Cafe serves lunch on sourdough toast and toasted ciabatta. Guacamole tops the chicken salad toast, while the presses feature roasted red peppers and arugula alongside their savory fillings.

The Hampton's Chicken Salad Toast mixes chicken with celery; Illmatic Prosciutto Press pairs prosciutto with mozzarella; Passaic Ave Turkey Pesto Press layers turkey with pesto aioli.

Visit Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Pair your press with french fries or a side salad; mixed greens with house-made vinaigrette accompany the turkey option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer lunch takeout or delivery?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for lunch throughout the Nutley area. Order your lunch online for convenient pickup or delivery.