Pastries in Nutley

Sweet and savory pastries at Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley include croissants, cakes and rolls, with pickup available for your order.

Order online

Pastries to Try

Almond Croissant

Almond croissant, a flaky pastry with an almond filling.

Almond Croissant with Nutella$6.75An almond croissant served with Nutella, adding a chocolate-hazelnut flavor to the pastry.
Almond Croissant with Strawberries$6.75An almond croissant served with strawberries for a fruity addition to the pastry.
Almond Croissant with Bananas and Strawberries$7.25An almond croissant served with bananas and strawberries for a combination of fresh fruit.
Almond Croissant with Mixed Berries$7.25An almond croissant served with mixed berries for a fruit-forward variation of the pastry.
Almond Croissant with Egg and Cheese$10.75An almond croissant paired with egg and cheese for a savory breakfast variation of the pastry.
Almond Croissant with Egg, Cheese, and Bacon$12.75An almond croissant paired with egg, cheese, and regular bacon for a savory breakfast option.

“Super cute spot, went to get some work done there. I was able to plug in.. have a latte and a yummy almond croissant. Will go back.”

“I saw this place on TikTok & happened to be in the area. The setting is very cozy & was decorated so cute for the holidays. The holiday drink menu is so fun & the gingerbread chai was delicious! The breakfast sandwich was simple but so tasty and the almond croissant was very good! Definitely would visit again, the menu has many other options I did not get to try. The staff was super friendly and welcoming, especially Stella. She was so kind! I will be back.”

Plain Croissant

A flaky, layered pastry with a buttery texture, served plain.

“Such an adorable cafe. The menu is surprisingly extensive. Many healthy items to order. Many decadent items such as milkshakes and croissants. Waitstaff if great. This would great for a small “shower”.”

Bread Pudding

$6.50

Warm bread pudding comes topped with caramel drizzle and powdered sugar.

“Pretty nice ambiance. Eye catching up walls. Every thing is tasty and well presented. Staff is humble and sweet. A small area for celebration. Menu have tea, coffee, milkshakes, snacks , breakfast snacks , pastries. Parking is available at the behind of the cafe. Various places where you can click pictures. The best thing is the lights are perfectly placed all your photos will be awesome . Spend good time.”

Cake Pop

$4.00

A small cake treat comes shaped on a stick for easy handling.

“Beautiful design and comfort, the eats looked surprisingly good (I got the acai bowl which was just what I needed). Name is appropriate, lots of sweetness about the place. And the pastries are well-proportioned.”

Cheddar Scallion Scone

$5.50

A cheddar and scallion scone with savory cheese and onion flavors.

“This place is a great stop to get some cool (and yummy coffee) and a light pastry! The cafe itself is gorgeous and worth the trip itself!”

Chocolate Croissant

$5.50

Flaky croissant pastry filled with chocolate.

“Servers were extremely nice .I enjoyed all my Sweet Treats especially The Crossants.🥐.”

Cinnamon Roll

$5.50

A soft spiral pastry filled with cinnamon sugar.

“I absolutely love this place it never disappoints. The food is amazing and the pastries are to die for.”

Monkey Bread

$4.75

Monkey bread is a pull-apart pastry made from baked dough pieces.

“It's a very Instagramable place. The latte art was fun and their monkey bread is amazing! I believe it can get busy. I was lucky to go at a slow time.”

Crumb Cake

$4.75

Crumb cake topped with a distinct layer of buttery crumbs.

Find Something Special at Sugar Tree Cafe

At Sugar Tree Cafe, pastries include the savory combination of cheddar and scallion in a scone, cinnamon in a rolled pastry, crumb-topped cake and cake pops, with monkey bread also available.

Try Plain Croissant with egg and cheese, Chocolate Croissant with mixed berries, or Almond Croissant with bananas and strawberries; Nutella is another option you can add to any of these croissants.

Order in Nutley with pickup, dine-in or delivery. Bread Pudding is served warm with caramel drizzle and powdered sugar; add a scoop of chocolate or vanilla ice cream to its soft, buttery sweetness.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pastries throughout the Nutley area. Order your pastries online for convenient pickup or delivery.