Milkshakes in Nutley

“I absolutely love this place!! The environment is sooo floral and so chic. Definitely a place worth going back to. The menu has so many options… so what I got was the sugar tree omelette and it was so good .. especially if you are a fan of goat cheese! The other plate it matcha pancakes and that was so bomb and definitely worth it. The drinks were pomegranate raspberry tea and banana pudding milkshake. The workers were super friendly and well oriented.”

“Such an adorable cafe. The menu is surprisingly extensive. Many healthy items to order. Many decadent items such as milkshakes and croissants. Waitstaff if great. This would great for a small “shower”.”

“Perfect Sunday brunch !! Beautiful atmosphere and delicious food . Lobster tostadas were superb , 5 start french toast and out of this world milk shakes 🤩🤩”

“SPECTACULAR!! SHOW STOPPING!! The Mac and cheese was exceptional! The milkshakes were handcrafted to perfection! If I could snap my fingers and teleport there anytime I was hungry, I would. But trust, I will be making an appearance again. My group came here to bond and left feeling like a family! Shoutout our server Mae!”

“The milkshake was amazing + pesto turkey press is very tasty. Fresh salad. Awesome aesthetics.”

“Pretty nice ambiance. Eye catching up walls. Every thing is tasty and well presented. Staff is humble and sweet. A small area for celebration. Menu have tea, coffee, milkshakes, snacks , breakfast snacks , pastries. Parking is available at the behind of the cafe. Various places where you can click pictures. The best thing is the lights are perfectly placed all your photos will be awesome . Spend good time.”

“Love this place. Kids love it. Great coffee, food, milkshakes, and service!”

“This place is amazing! I always order a milkshake from them and they never disappoint! I get the Oreo milkshake and it is always so good. Sometimes there may be a bit of a wait for then to make the milkshakes but it is totally worth it!”

“Cute place! Very tasty milkshakes!”

“The staff are friendly and welcoming. We enjoyed our time here. The food options are good and seasoned fries are worth a try. You will enjoy the options of coffee and tea as well as specialty milkshakes. They even have a vegan milkshake for those that want to have something sweet.”

“Loved it. Their shakes are amazing.”

“Beautiful and clean inside. Kenneth, May and all of the staff are friendly and provided great service. Shakes, pancakes and everything else we tried were delicious. We highly recommend Sugar Tree Cafe.”

“Always excellent customer service and the food is absolutely mind-blowing. The tables are well-spaced out and is even spacious for a cafe. The decor makes the cafe. The atmosphere is so nice and bright. This spot is perfect for a day out for brunch. The milkshakes are everything you want and more and they even have vegan options.”

“They’ve improved so much since they opened, but of course that’s with any new business! Staff is great and the food is amazing. Ambience is nice for pictures and I went one day where LJDJs was actually playing some music. I specifically go here for the sticky wings and the vegan joy. (I’m not vegan nor vegetarian if you’re wondering)”