Skip to main content
Brownie

Desserts in Nutley

Sweet bakes and filled crepes are among the desserts at Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley, with pickup available for your dessert order.

Order online

Desserts to Try

“Very warm and inviting atmosphere! The food was delicious! Highly recommend the Nutella crepe! Are server Stella was very sweet and attentive. It was our first visit but it won't be our last.”

“Kristel is very kind! The food and drinks were delicious. We got the Nutella Crepe and the Passaic Ave Breakfast!”

Brownie

$4.50

A classic chocolate brownie with a dense, baked texture.

“I’ve been to Sugar Tree a number of times and I’ve never left disappointed! The food is consistently delicious — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Whether you're stopping in for brunch, lunch, or a sweet treat, everything on the menu is a hit. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the staff are always friendly and attentive, especially Stella who went above and beyond. It’s such a fun spot to relax, catch up on work, socialize with friends, or just treat yourself. Highly recommend!”

Cinnamon Roll

$5.50

A soft spiral pastry filled with cinnamon sugar.

“Not only is this cafe beautifully decorated with great food and desserts, but the service is unbeatable. I walked in with my 2 kids on a rainy afternoon and ordered a drink and some treats for my girls. The very sweet lady helping me gave me the order on the house and didn’t even make a big deal about it, it truly made my day more that I Can say. We have been here a couple of times before and have also had great experiences each time. Thank you for making my day, from one mamma to another 🤗🤗”

Crumb Cake

$4.75

Crumb cake topped with a distinct layer of buttery crumbs.

“I highly recommend this cafe for anyone looking for a relaxing spot to enjoy a cup of coffee and a sweet treat. The quality of the food and drinks, combined with the great service and cozy atmosphere, made for a wonderful experience. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with comfortable seating and tasteful decor.”

Find Something Special at Sugar Tree Cafe

Sugar Tree Cafe's desserts include a Nutella Crepe filled with Nutella and topped with fresh bananas and/or strawberries, whipped cream, and powdered sugar, alongside cake, rolls, brownies, and pudding.

Bread Pudding is served warm with rich, buttery flavor, caramel drizzle, and powdered sugar. Add chocolate or vanilla ice cream for $2 more; Cake Pop and Brownie are also available for your dessert.

Order your desserts from Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Cinnamon Roll features cinnamon in a rolled bake, while Crumb Cake pairs its cake base with a crumb topping.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for desserts throughout the Nutley area. Order your desserts online for convenient pickup or delivery.