American Food in Nutley

Sweet breakfasts and savory comfort dishes make American food at Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley a satisfying choice for pickup.

Order online

Breakfast

Deep Fried Cinnamon Toast

$17.85

Brioche fried in cinnamon batter with berries and maple syrup.

“A Cozy atmosphere, five-star service, beautiful décor, and food/beverages that did not disappoint. Everything was freshly made and packed with flavor. We ordered the deep-fried cinnamon French toast, skirt steak and eggs, and the Passaic ave Breakfast, plus a hot chocolate and latte, so good! Huge thanks to Jack for taking great care of us (and helping with lighting for our photos!) and to Jaime for her patience and assistance at checkout. We will definitely be back!”

Morning Bliss

$13.75

A French toast sandwich with eggs, bacon, melted cheese, and syrup.

“Honestly some reviews are harsh on here but i can honestly say that the food was great. Very cute ambiance and staff was nice. My friend and me had the avocado toast along with the french toast. Both meals were really good! Will be coming back!”

Passaic Ave Breakfast

$14.25

Two eggs come with home fries, roasted tomato, toast, and a meat choice.

“This place is very cozy. The food and service it’s excellent. I had the Passaic Ave Breakfast and really enjoyed it. Our waitress Stella was very attentive, and nice. I would definitely come back.”

Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese

$7.50

Taylor ham, egg, and melted cheese fill a warm breakfast roll.

“Had the Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich and a cappuccino recently. Great meal, great coffee and I loved the presentation. With the beautiful atmosphere and welcoming staff I received makes this a top place to visit. 10/10 will highly recommend to my colleagues in the area.”

Pancakes

STC Pancakes

Three fluffy pancakes come with strawberries, cream, and maple syrup.

“Stella was amazing! She is so friendly and caring made our day♥️ the food was great, the pancake was my best 😋 I'll come back here again”

“I absolutely love this place!! The environment is sooo floral and so chic. Definitely a place worth going back to. The menu has so many options… so what I got was the sugar tree omelette and it was so good .. especially if you are a fan of goat cheese! The other plate it matcha pancakes and that was so bomb and definitely worth it. The drinks were pomegranate raspberry tea and banana pudding milkshake. The workers were super friendly and well oriented.”

Chicken

Cafe Sticky Wings

$14.00

Chicken wings seasoned with garlic, onion, Old Bay, and spices.

“They’ve improved so much since they opened, but of course that’s with any new business! Staff is great and the food is amazing. Ambience is nice for pictures and I went one day where LJDJs was actually playing some music. I specifically go here for the sticky wings and the vegan joy. (I’m not vegan nor vegetarian if you’re wondering)”

Chicken and Waffle

$16.00

Crispy chicken tops a buttery waffle with Sugar Tree sauce and pickles.

“Had an amazing experience at Sugar Tree today! Our server, Stella, was fantastic super attentive, friendly, and made the whole visit feel smooth and welcoming. I ordered The Notorious BLT and Chicken & Waffles, and both dishes were incredible. The BLT was stacked perfectly with great flavor, and the Chicken & Waffles hit that perfect balance of crispy, juicy, and sweet. I also had two Lotus drinks, which were extremely refreshing and paired perfectly with the meal. The atmosphere was wonderful, cozy, clean, and overall a great vibe. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to. Highly recommend!”

Chicken Fingers & Fries

$13.75

Crispy chicken tenders served with crunchy French fries.

“The food was good, we had the açaí bowl, hot tea, and chicken tenders w/ ff… this place is a hidden gem 💎 it’s very cozy and so cute inside.”

Chicken Club

$15.00

Grilled chicken club with avocado, bacon, tomato, and smoked cheese.

Pasta

Cast Iron Mac N Cheese

Pasta in creamy cheese sauce, finished with shredded cheddar.

“SPECTACULAR!! SHOW STOPPING!! The Mac and cheese was exceptional! The milkshakes were handcrafted to perfection! If I could snap my fingers and teleport there anytime I was hungry, I would. But trust, I will be making an appearance again. My group came here to bond and left feeling like a family! Shoutout our server Mae!”

“Came here with 3 friends and wow… the food was delishhh. The service was exceptional from start to finish, which made the whole experience even better. We basically turned brunch into a tasting, and yes I tried all of my friends dishes lol, from the chicken sandwich, chicken & waffles, mac and cheese, and the Notorious B.L.T… and honestly, every single dish hit. Highly recommend this spot for brunch. You really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu !”

From the Kitchen at Sugar Tree Cafe

Sugar Tree Cafe serves American food with sweet breakfast dishes and savory sandwiches. Crispy fried chicken tops a buttery waffle with Sugar Tree sauce, tangy pickles, and dressed mixed greens.

Cast Iron Mac N Cheese has velvety cheese sauce and shredded cheddar. Cafe Sticky Wings feature Thai chili sauce. Morning Bliss layers French toast with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, cheese, and syrup.

Visit Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley for dine-in, pickup, or delivery. STC Pancakes feature three fluffy pancakes topped with whipped cream, maple syrup, sliced strawberries, and a dusting of powdered sugar.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for american food throughout the Nutley area. Order your american food online for convenient pickup or delivery.