Skip to main content
Nutley Chicken Sandwich

Chicken in Nutley

Savory chicken dishes at Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley range from pasta to sandwiches, with pickup available for your next meal.

Order online

Chicken to Try

Ariana's Tuscan Chicken with Penne Pasta

$22.00

Penne with sliced chicken, spinach, and sun-dried tomatoes.

“The pasta is delicious!! This place is 10/10”

Cafe Sticky Wings

$14.00

Chicken wings seasoned with garlic, onion, Old Bay, and spices.

“They’ve improved so much since they opened, but of course that’s with any new business! Staff is great and the food is amazing. Ambience is nice for pictures and I went one day where LJDJs was actually playing some music. I specifically go here for the sticky wings and the vegan joy. (I’m not vegan nor vegetarian if you’re wondering)”

Chicken and Waffle

$16.00

Crispy chicken tops a buttery waffle with Sugar Tree sauce and pickles.

“Had an amazing experience at Sugar Tree today! Our server, Stella, was fantastic super attentive, friendly, and made the whole visit feel smooth and welcoming. I ordered The Notorious BLT and Chicken & Waffles, and both dishes were incredible. The BLT was stacked perfectly with great flavor, and the Chicken & Waffles hit that perfect balance of crispy, juicy, and sweet. I also had two Lotus drinks, which were extremely refreshing and paired perfectly with the meal. The atmosphere was wonderful, cozy, clean, and overall a great vibe. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to. Highly recommend!”

Nutley Chicken Sandwich

$15.50

A chicken sandwich, with its specific bread and toppings not listed.

“Came here with 3 friends and wow… the food was delishhh. The service was exceptional from start to finish, which made the whole experience even better. We basically turned brunch into a tasting, and yes I tried all of my friends dishes lol, from the chicken sandwich, chicken & waffles, mac and cheese, and the Notorious B.L.T… and honestly, every single dish hit. Highly recommend this spot for brunch. You really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu !”

Prepared the Sugar Tree Cafe Way

Sugar Tree Cafe's chicken dishes include penne with garlic-parmesan cream sauce, spinach and sun-dried tomatoes, plus shredded chicken salad on sourdough with celery, vegan mayonnaise and guacamole.

Chicken Club pairs grilled chicken with avocado and bacon. Chicken Fingers & Fries comes with crunchy French fries, while Cafe Sticky Wings has garlic, Old Bay and Sweet Baby Ray's Thai Chili sauce.

Visit Sugar Tree Cafe in Nutley for dine-in, pickup or delivery. Chicken And Waffle sets crispy fried chicken on a buttery waffle with Sugar Tree sauce, tangy pickles and fresh dressed mixed greens.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for chicken throughout the Nutley area. Order your chicken online for convenient pickup or delivery.